|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
The Honorable Jon S. Corzine Dear Governor Corzine, The vitality of New Jersey’s recreational fishing industry, which generates 1.3 billion dollars to New Jersey’s economy, is being seriously threatened by a recent ruling by a Brooklyn, New York Federal judge concerning the data and methodology used to establish quotas for summer flounder, locally known as fluke, for East coast states. The Jersey Coast Anglers Association (JCAA) represents over 75 fishing clubs throughout the Garden State. The JCAA, on behalf of its members, requests that New Jersey intervene along with the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) and the Secretary of the federal Department of Commerce to challenge the case brought by the state of New York to change the coastwide allocation of summer flounder. Further, the JCAA is concerned that Brooklyn’s Senior Federal District Judge Charles P. Sifton has made an unprecedented change to the status of the ASMFC, which, if left to stand, leaves the ASMFC at the mercy of the courts in the allocation of species under its management regime. The judge found for the state of New York and a coalition made up of the United Boatman of New York (UBNY), the New York Fishing Tackle Trade Association (NYFTTA), and the Fishermen’s Conservation Association of New York (FCA). to include the ASMFC in the lawsuit. The summer flounder fishery, one of the most important to our state, is jointly managed by the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) and the ASMFC. The NMFS has management responsibilities over fisheries within three to 200 miles and the ASMFC is responsible for the waters from New Jersey’s shoreline to three miles out to sea. For nearly twenty years now, each state has been allocated a catch limit based upon its historical catch. Because if its large participation by anglers, New Jersey has historically had the largest allocation of any state. In the mid-90s, for the first time, a coastwide quota was set for all the coastal states where each competed for the quota. After being in place for several years, this system was found to be unfair to some states and it was agreed by all parties that a change to the coastwide system needed to occur. The current state-by-state system was determined over twenty years ago by extensive discussion by the coastal states to come up with a fair and equitable system. Ironically, it was New York that made the motion to switch from a coastwide to state-by-state model. If New York is successful in changing back to a single coastwide quota system, then New York anglers will be able to increase their catch at the expense of New Jersey anglers. As a result, New Jersey’s catch will be substantially decreased. This will have a significant negative economic impact on New Jersey’s economy during these troubled financial times. The JCAA members are deeply concerned that this legal decision may result in a court-mandated injunction that would disrupt the 2009 summer flounder season for New Jersey’s anglers. Because of the large impact a federal ruling could have in this matter, we again request that New Jersey’s interest be represented by our Attorney General as a friend of the court. Tom Fote is the Governor’s Appointee to the ASMFC and can provide the more detailed information the Attorney General’s office needs to assist New Jersey’s anglers in this most urgent matter. Tom can be reached at (732) 270-9102. Bruce Freeman (732-793-7871) is a past employee of the Division of Fish and Wildlife and was NJ’s representative to Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission and Mid-Atlantic Fisheries Management Council for over 25 years. He has helped the Attorney General’s office in the past and would be willing to help again as a volunteer. |